plaintiff and defendant

chapter four of the text discusses an analogy involving documentary viewed as a courtroom setting. the documentary filmmaker is the judge, plaintiff, and defendant. it covers these topics in a couple different topics: plaintiff and defendant, credibility, witnesses, cross examination, order and selection in presenting evidence, and summing up. this analogy applies in the case of Blue Vinyl a documentary by judith hefland. the filmmaker has a weird feeling when her parents take down the wood siding on the family home and decide to replace it with blue vinyl simulated wood grain siding. her parents decide on the siding because of the look and cost, judith senses there is treachery afoot. she identifies the plaintiff initially as herself and her parents, the defendant turns out to be the vinyl corporations, in america in particular is lake charles louisiana and even vinyl business as far off as venice italy. she finds greenpeace witnesses, lawyers for victims of vinyl, the victims themselves, and reputable scientists for her witnesses on the side of the plaintiff and the vinyl public relations people as the witnesses of the defendant. their credibility is established somewhat in the identification of their positions and job titles and educational history in some cases. judith is the lawyer for both sides in that she cross examines every person to get to the bottom of what turns out to be an ugly tale. she then turns around and uses this evidence and facts and hearsay and presents it to the jury which is the audience. she uses this evidence to show the argument for both sides. Blue Vinyl is a reflexive documentary maybe self reflexive in that it inserts the filmmaker herself into this story of a product that most people dont think any thing about, i have a friend whose kids were taken away with his estranged girlfriend who happens to be from lake charles louisiana. after surviving hurricane katrina in biloxi mississippi, it turns out to be a double edged knife when i found out that she took them to live in what appears to be one of the most dangerous places to live (and especially raise kids) in america. once again to be able to find such a small topic like seemingly harmless vinyl (which everyone, including me, has on their house is a real shock and i look forward to its conclusion to find out how miss hefland sums up her case before the jury (me).

here is the link to view this topic

http://www.bluevinyl.org/